Along my professional career, I have been asked many times to provide “a general idea” of the tax consequences of a particular problem. I always decline.

Usually, the request also comes with a statement that is usually couched in these, or similar terms:  “it will only take you a few minutes”.

Let’s talk about the issues this raises, and why, in the almost twenty years I have been licensed to practice law, I have yet to opine verbally on a tax matter.

When it comes to transactions, most people come to tax attorneys because they are facing a choice in courses of action.  In their gut, they know that whatever choice they make may have a tax consequence.  What will that be?  The outcome is usually very important, for large amounts of money, tax penalties, and interest may be at stake.  Sometimes, it’s a person’s liberty that may hang in the balance.

Persons who are unfamiliar with the complexities and intricacies of the law of taxation lamentably assume that a “general answer” will suffice.  As many of my colleagues will attest, there are rules, but then there can be exceptions to the exceptions to the exceptions. Oftentimes, the “general answer” will be wrong for the facts, and relying on the “general answer” will likely lead to a bad outcome.

From the outset, there are challenges unique to tax law.  Defining the facts on which a tax opinion will be based on, is a skill in itself.  In taxation, all relevant facts must be explored and developed.  Sometimes, a particular fact is simply not known or cannot be ascertained.  If it is relevant, it must still be accounted for.  Clients may not fully be aware that a particular fact is very relevant to their matter!

Tax opinions begin with a complete recitation of all the relevant facts on which the opinion is based.  Good opinions also warn that any deviation in the facts may render the opinion invalid.  The task of collecting all the pertinent facts therefore resides in the hands of the attorney drafting the opinion.

Then there’s the issue of finding the applicable law and applying it to the facts.  There’s the Internal Revenue Code, all its regulations, Revenue Rulings, Private letter Rulings, Chief Counsel Memoranda, Revenue Procedures, instructions on tax forms, cases from the U.S. Tax Court, every single federal district court in the United States (94 of them), the Court of Claims, the 12 Courts of Appeal for the Circuits, and the U.S. Supreme Court.  There’s also tax treaties that may come into play.  And it is seldom I see a tax problem that also does not have a state and local angle.  Repeat for each of the states, and some local jurisdictions too.  To make it even more exciting, tax law changes constantly.  Tax attorneys and others in the industry must spend inordinate amounts of time just to stay on top of the latest ruling, court case, or development.  That takes time, effort and energy.  Some clients may not know about or wish to begin to understand.

Some problems are income tax cases.  Some involve estate, gift, generation skipping transfer, franchise, net worth, excise, employment taxes, real and personal property taxation….some involve multiple states, several countries…it can get hairy quickly.

And it should of course, only take “a few minutes”.  It really does not.  While some really wish for free advice and do not want to pay a fee, others just may not fully appreciate the enormity of the training, education and experience needed to get these things right.

If the opinion is not right, the client will come knocking, lawsuit in hand, because the client relied to his or her detriment in what he or she were told.  That’s why written opinions provide the clearest assurance to both client and attorney.

You wish for solid tax advice? Retain one of us.  You want general advice? Buy a book.



07/03/2015 2:21am

I really impress when i read your opinion on this blog about tax. I want to improve some tax related doubt in my mind. So i visit this blog and i am satisfy when i read it fully.

02/02/2017 3:13am

Testomenix it no longer most effective motivates the employees however additionally art work like a marketing Testomenix agent for the business enterprise. it's miles very important to choose attractive or appealing presents.


02/12/2016 11:06am

Before we get into the gist of the discussion, your best recourse in cases like these (namely tax consequences and other things) would be to run them through to your accountant or financial adviser as they will have more of an idea regarding the subject. But for other references, please visit childcaresales.com.au.

05/25/2016 3:12am

The best opinion has more valuable things in our society. It deals with the more effective for the human being life. This is only for the main stream of the human being life. This is only for the freshness and too much important for the best side of the human being.

10/26/2016 3:15am

If you want to download HD movies easier, therefore showbox is the only solution for you.

02/02/2017 11:27pm

Alpha Monster Advanced as in lots of elements of life stability is the key to pinnacle-best fitness and nicely-being. to gain hormonal and physical stability you have to cross for Alpha Monster Advanced proper carrying activities and eat food that comprise proper sufficient quantities.


07/09/2016 2:07am

Hello me and my friend who works in childcaresales.com.au as business advisor, Before going into an obligation settlement or obligation pardoning program, you ought to know that you could be solid for assessments on the excused sum. Today, an expanding number of individuals are ending up under water that they can't pay down.

07/19/2016 4:56am

Hi all

10/13/2016 4:22am

The overall market is very strange now! Thanks a lot for this helpful post ;) Like your blog!

02/04/2017 12:11am

Biogenic XR using letting them recognize you're there to help them concentrate to them and train them a way to listen to their innate intestine instincts whilst round new Biogenic XR human beings are real beginnings to a foundation of safety in opposition.



Our Ecommerce Website Design and Development Services provide complete solution for generating online sales to our clients. Professional Design and Commercial understanding will generate more ROI.

01/22/2017 10:47pm

I am thankful to this blog for assisting me. I added some specified clues which are really important for me to use them in my writing skill. Really helpful stuff made by this blog.

02/06/2017 1:27am

Alpha Monster Advanced the mind muscle connection throughout each set handiest growing weight in small increments when you are assured that form is best. Alpha Monster Advanced it is regrettably very easy to turn out to be satisfied that because you have not introduced weight.


01/23/2017 11:15pm

Do the pathology test with Acromad sample collection services in Bhopal who offers best sample collection services within discounted amount. Fast report processing with accurate results.">

02/05/2017 3:28pm

Presently for the most regular confusion that individuals have when getting some information about what is FHA credit. They accept that it is a credit straightforwardly issued from government impose stores.

02/06/2017 11:08pm

Alpha X Boost even professional bodybuilders which might be taking anabolism steroids or different performance enhancing drugs can't produce quick gains.the preliminary Alpha X Boost place that starting bodybuilders appearance.


02/07/2017 11:30pm

Azienda Collagen Serum you face slightly within the evening and wash it off. this could assist the dust dust and filth get off your face and leaves you searching radiant and healthful. Azienda Collagen Serum similarly to this the products for frame care also can cast.


02/08/2017 11:16pm

Alpha Monster Advanced people who do not supply a damn what they consume.get good enough sleep. it's a truth that maximum individuals need nine hours of sleep day Alpha Monster Advanced by day. you can attain this instantly via the night or with 6-8 hours in the course.



Alpha Monster Advanced if you can remain lively and maintain the aches and pains at bay you simply taken a super leap forward in a longer healthier happier lifestyles. Alpha Monster Advanced that s in reality worth a experience to the fitness center.the benefit to fitness.


02/13/2017 1:30am

Alpha X Boost do you want to hold fit especially as you skip your the solution would be a specific sure. aerobic exercising gives you all that and extra. if you contain your Alpha X Boost self in some kind of aerobic workout each day the hazard of living.


02/13/2017 10:52pm

Alpha X Boost to muscle as you figure out many of these products are available powder substances which are blended with water and are all herbal. as well with the Alpha X Boost powders you can without problems make a shake via combining.


02/17/2017 2:40am

Testo Muscle Fuel it weighs the hair down and continues it from growing over time. our merchandise deal with all reasons of hair loss by attacking dht with our Testo Muscle Fuel personal blend of amino and other organic acids.through concentrated on dht.


02/17/2017 10:24pm

Testo Ultra its fact there is a sizeable opportunity for guys in modeling industry. it simpler for guys to start new career as style model. due to the fact maximum of Testo Ultra modeling corporation seeking out male version. so in case you want to come.


02/19/2017 10:01pm

Pure Nitro Max if you need to get the most gain from your muscle building ordinary, you need to stay faraway from the maximum commonplace motives that cause Pure Nitro Max humans to now not be triumphant at constructing muscle and gaining weight.


02/20/2017 9:41pm

Alpha X Boost moreover even though a protein contains all the amino acids if it does not contain them in the amounts that we need it can't be called a whole protein.Alpha X Boost the frame building gain mass muscle dietary supplements that comprise.


02/21/2017 10:28pm

TestoUltra most cancers but not taking action till the circumstance worsens or expands. active surveillance is used while a affected person won't be capable of go TestoUltra through remedy due to complications from other situations or is in any other case unable.


02/22/2017 10:24pm

Testo Ultra bill thru the usa senate suggests a shift in us mindset toward software program outsourcing.it is excessive time software program development organizations Testo Ultra discover new locations to export their it services.


02/23/2017 10:27pm

Kamasutra Male Enhancement herbal breast expansion is an all-natural breast augmentation complement that proven secure and effective in then progressively Kamasutra Male Enhancement improving the size and shape of your breasts. surgical treatment continually difficulty.


02/24/2017 10:26pm

Andronite Enhanced apart from these herbal causes of baldness there are also baldness due to clinical situations together with one that undergone chemotherapy Andronite Enhanced because of most cancers excessive fever ringworm within the scalp diverse.


02/26/2017 10:28pm

Muscle X TST 1700 a treatment for bis is tough to find because the medical career does not what reasons bis. one feasible reason is a breakdown of the peristalsis motion. Muscle X TST 1700 the manner peristalsis works is thru contraction and relaxation of the bowel wall.


02/27/2017 10:46pm

Andronite Enhanced family chores in addition to assign herself to other fields of activities that hobby her. girls have to be unfastened to perform some thing they wish to pursue.Andronite Enhanced one such interest which we now locate an increasing number.


03/15/2017 9:52pm

04/01/2017 5:10am

04/02/2017 3:40am

04/20/2017 3:38am

Be thankful you all are can visit on this site, because it can get real-time news and still warm for free

05/02/2017 12:00am

Really a great post

05/02/2017 5:44am

Nice Post

07/05/2017 1:51pm

Nice article and such a good information. Thanks for your excellent posting. I really enjoyed reading this blog.


We provide best cheap flip flops toe rings & gladiator sandals cheap. So visit our site for gabor toe loop sandals, toe loop sandals leather online


Leave a Reply